Market Expectations: Why mortgage rates are rising even though the Fed cut rates
Nov 17, 2024I don't think I can say this enough: expectations are the most important thing we can manage in life. π³
This is true for real estate professionals managing their clients' expectations.
And for spouses, parents, and friends managing the expectations of those around them.
Why?
Because all frustrations in life stem from missed expectations. π‘
- You expected to get Ruth's Chris, but you got Steak n Shake instead..
- You expected to see them, but they had to work late..
- They expected to close on the house tomorrow, but now It's delayed a week..
Sometimes, even positive surprises are bad if you're the type that doesn't like anything unexpected to happen.
How does this relate to interest rates and the Fed? π€
Because the market's expectations around Fed rate cuts weren't met and now mortgage rates are moving higher..
We all get ahead of ourselves
Outside of the election and the Jake Paul vs. Mike Tyson fight, the Fed finally cutting interest rates was one of the most anticipated events of the last 12 months. π¬
And we finally got what we've been waiting for: the Fed cut interest rates. π
Except now that it's here, it's not as awesome as we expected.
From the day the Fed cut rates, mortgage rates have gone up. π€¬
It's totally confusing to get this outcome - unless you understand the point we started with about expectations.
You see, we got ahead of ourselves twice now. βοΈ
First, towards the end of 2023.
Mortgage rates dropped ~25% as investors began expecting Fed rate cuts in the near future.
The expectations bubbled up and reached a peak when everyone thought we'd get 6 Fed cuts to start off 2024.
And then we didn't get any cuts. π±
Expectations were missed and rates rebounded higher by nearly as much as they had fallen. π
Second, we hit the repeat button as investors expected another 6 Fed cuts to end 2024.
Mortgage rates declined ~20% in anticipation, only to be met by a Fed who reluctantly cut and warned investors were expecting too much. π€
And back up mortgage rates went..
Finding Opportunity
This brings us to today.
We've got a Fed who's cut rates twice, but mortgage rates that have gone up nearly 25% since the first cut was announced. π΅π«
This isn't because of the actual Fed cut rates.
It's because investors are walking back their expectations of the 4 other cuts in the future. π²
As we lower our expectations (in the market and life) it can be painful and we might throw a tantrum or two.
We thought we'd get something that we're no longer getting.
Now, this doesn't mean mortgage rates won't come back down in the future. π€·βοΈ
But, it highlights some important takeaways we should keep in mind:
β The market is always looking ahead. It's not as much today's action that matters as much as what everyone expects in the future.
β This is why you don't need to wait for the Fed to cut rates to get the best deal. The best time to act is when expectations are at their highest.
β Missed expectations can cause more damage than the actions themselves. In business and life, focus on underpromising and overdelivering as much as possible. Keep this in mind during every deal you work.
β Because people overreact, you can expect it to happen both ways. We went from expecting too much to possibly expecting too little. I think we could see a reversal in mortgage rates in the coming months. Be ready to act if that happens.
When things seem to be going in one direction, they're ripe for a reversal. π’
Don't wait for the Fed to take action thinking it will get you the best deal.
Act when expectations are extreme and you might get the best deal of all. π
Dr. Alex Stewart
Founder
Are you a real estate agent and looking to grow your business using information like this?
Here's 3 ways to dive deeper:
- π― Market Insiders Coaching Membership: Join an exclusive group of Realtors focused on becoming experts in our local Jacksonville market. This membership gives you access to monthly live coaching from yours truly, a member-only community for private updates and discussions, and additional resources to address clients questions and supercharge your business.
Rated 9.65 out of 10 for value to their business by my members. - π©π» Digital Course: How to Use Market Stats in Your Business: Accelerate your business growth by learning how to use data. This course will help you more easily understand the market, improve your client presentations, and increase your conversion rate with clients. No finance degree required as I lay everything out in very simple terms.
Rated 9.84 out of 10 for value to their business by 100+ Realtors. - π Schedule a live presentation: Want to learn in person? I offer the MarketPulse 360 presentation that connects all the dots (national to local) so you get a comprehensive breakdown of today's market. It's 2 hours of beautiful charts designed to give you all the major trends you need to know about and address the most common questions in the market. You'll walk out feeling more confident, with resources to use in your business, and a level above the rest of the Realtors who are wandering around blindly.
Rated 9.74 out of 10 for value to their business by 600+ Realtors.